Skip to main content

Christian Brothers Sexual Abuse

The Christian Brothers and child sexual abuse in Australian institutions

The Christian Brothers ran some of Australia’s best-known Catholic boys’ schools, as well as orphanages and farm schools for boys. The Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse found that more than one in five Christian Brothers who ministered in Australia between 1950 and 2010 were alleged perpetrators of child sexual abuse.

This article sets out the history of the order in Australia, what the Royal Commission and the courts have found at particular schools, and what survivors’ options are today, including after the Christian Brothers’ 2026 scheme of arrangement.

Some matters described in this article are allegations that have not been tested in court. Where a person has been convicted, we say so.

History of the Christian Brothers in Australia

Christian Brothers in AustraliaThe Christian Brothers are a Catholic religious order founded in Ireland in 1802 by Edmund Rice to provide education and welfare for poor boys. The first Christian Brothers came to Sydney in 1843 but left in 1847. In 1868, a small group led by Brother Patrick Ambrose Treacy arrived in Melbourne and established a permanent presence.

As demand for Catholic education grew, so did the order. The Australasian Province of the Christian Brothers was formally established in 1885, with its administration based first in Melbourne, then Petersham from 1897, and Strathfield from 1908. Over more than 150 years, the Christian Brothers educated many thousands of Australian boys and ran a number of residential homes for boys.

In 2007, the order established Edmund Rice Education Australia (EREA) to take over the governance of its schools. Most former Christian Brothers schools are now run by EREA or by a Catholic diocese.

Year Key event
1802 Christian Brothers founded in Ireland by Edmund Rice
1843 First Christian Brothers arrive in Sydney (they leave in 1847)
1868 Permanent presence established in Melbourne under Brother Patrick Ambrose Treacy
1885 Australasian Province of the Christian Brothers established
2007 Edmund Rice Education Australia established to run the order’s schools
2014 Royal Commission public hearing into four Christian Brothers institutions in Western Australia (Case Study 11)
2017 Royal Commission data shows 22% of Christian Brothers who ministered between 1950 and 2010 were alleged perpetrators
2019 Reported that the order had paid more than $213 million in compensation and legal costs over the previous six years
2026 The order seeks a creditors’ scheme of arrangement. EREA agrees to stand behind abuse claims, subject to creditor and court approval

What the Royal Commission found

Data released by the Royal Commission in February 2017 showed that 22% of Christian Brothers who ministered between 1950 and 2010 were alleged perpetrators. Among Catholic religious orders, only the Brothers of St John of God had a higher proportion, at more than 40%.

The Royal Commission examined the Christian Brothers in Case Study 11, which focused on the experiences of men who, as boys, lived at four Christian Brothers institutions in Western Australia: Castledare Junior Orphanage, St Vincent’s Orphanage Clontarf, St Mary’s Agricultural School Tardun, and Bindoon Farm School. In Case Study 28, the Commission examined Catholic Church authorities in Ballarat, including the Christian Brothers’ schools there.

A recurring theme in the evidence was that Brothers who were the subject of complaints were moved to other schools rather than being removed from contact with children or reported to police. That pattern allowed abuse to continue in new places.

St Alipius Boys' School, Ballarat East
St Alipius School

St Alipius, Ballarat

St Alipius Boys’ School in Ballarat East, Victoria, was staffed by the Christian Brothers until it closed in 1976. In Case Study 28, the Royal Commission heard evidence that sexual misconduct by Christian Brothers towards students was common knowledge around St Alipius and nearby St Patrick’s College, and concluded that the Christian Brothers’ response was grossly inadequate.

Four of the Brothers who taught at St Alipius, and its chaplain, the priest Gerald Ridsdale, were accused of sexually abusing children. All but one, who died before charges could be laid, have been convicted. They include Brother Edward Dowlan (now known as Ted Bales) and former headmaster Brother Robert Best. Read more in our articles on abuse in Ballarat and Gerald Ridsdale.

Edmund Rice College, Wollongong

Edmund Rice College is a boys’ high school in Wollongong, New South Wales. It was founded by the Christian Brothers in 1926 and moved to its West Wollongong campus in stages from 1962. It is now run by Edmund Rice Education Australia.

Former principal Brother Michael Evans is alleged to have abused boys while he was principal in the 1980s and early 1990s, including incidents alleged to have occurred in 1982 and 1984. The incidents were not reported at the time. In 1989 they were reported to a local Catholic priest, who informed police and the Bishop.

It is alleged that police declined to prosecute at the time after the Christian Brothers gave assurances that Brother Evans was receiving counselling. He remained principal for a further five years and was removed in 1994. Police later reopened the investigation, but Brother Evans died in 1994 before he could be charged.

Christian Brothers institutionIn 1995, the Wood Royal Commission into the New South Wales Police Service began examining allegations of organised paedophile networks in NSW. Volume V of its Final Report, the Paedophile Inquiry, includes a case study on Brother Evans and a Wollongong priest, Father Peter Lewis Comensoli, who pleaded guilty in 1994 to two charges of indecent assault. Father Peter Lewis Comensoli should not be confused with the current Archbishop of Melbourne, Peter Andrew Comensoli, who has not been the subject of any allegations of abuse.

Brother Evans was not the only Brother at the school who faced allegations. In 2016, Brother John Vincent Roberts pleaded guilty to 11 charges relating to the sexual abuse of a boy at the school in the late 1980s. In September 2016, he was sentenced to 10 years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of six years. Brother Roberts had been allowed to keep teaching despite at least one earlier complaint at another Christian Brothers school in NSW.

Stephen Jones MP, a former school captain of Edmund Rice College, said in 2016 that boys at the school in the 1980s knew to avoid being alone with certain Brothers, and described the school as a “dumping ground” for sex predators.

St Patrick’s College, Strathfield

Christian Brothers boarding dormitorySt Patrick’s College, Strathfield was established by the Christian Brothers in 1928.

Brother Michael Evans taught at the school in the 1970s and is alleged to have abused a 16-year-old student on a football camp in 1979. He later became principal of Edmund Rice College in Wollongong.

Other Brothers who taught at St Patrick’s have been convicted. In 2017, Brother Roger King was found guilty of sexual offences against boys at the school in the 1970s and 1980s. In 2018, Brother Desmond Eric (“Neil”) Richards, who was already in custody for other historical offences, received further jail time for offences against Year 5 and 6 students at St Patrick’s in 1986 and 1987.

Brother Richards is first known to have abused a child in 1962. He was moved between a number of Christian Brothers schools, and has been convicted of offences at schools in Albury, Wagga Wagga, East Gosford, and Strathfield. He was principal of St Edward’s College, East Gosford in the 1970s.

Compensation and the 2026 scheme of arrangement

After the Royal Commission, the Christian Brothers faced a large increase in civil claims. In 2019, it was reported that the order had paid more than $213 million in compensation and legal costs over the previous six years.

In June 2026, the Christian Brothers told the Supreme Court of New South Wales that they did not have enough money to meet all current and future abuse claims, and proposed a creditors’ scheme of arrangement. On 2 July 2026, the Court paused civil claims against the order nationally. On 24 July 2026, Edmund Rice Education Australia agreed, subject to creditor and court approval of a revised scheme, to become the defendant in Christian Brothers abuse claims and to pay settlements and judgments.

For what this means for your claim, including key dates and a comparison of civil claims with the National Redress Scheme, see our guide to Christian Brothers and Edmund Rice Education Australia abuse compensation claims.

Christian Brothers schools and institutions in Australia

Christian Brothers schools in AustraliaThe following schools and institutions were founded or staffed by the Christian Brothers. Many have since merged, been renamed, or closed, and most that remain open are now run by Edmund Rice Education Australia or a Catholic diocese. The list is not exhaustive. Inclusion on this list does not suggest that abuse occurred at a particular school.

Australian Capital Territory

School or institution Status and former names
St Edmund’s College, Canberra

New South Wales

School or institution Status and former names
Aquinas College, Albury Now Xavier High School
Christian Brothers College, Albury Now Xavier High School
Christian Brothers School, Balmain 1887-1990
Christian Brothers College, Bondi Beach Closed
Christian Brothers’ School, Broadway 1843-1847
Christian Brothers College, Burwood 1909-2009
Christian Brothers College, Manly Now St Paul’s Catholic College, Manly
Christian Brothers’ College, Newtown 1889-1970
Christian Brothers’ Technical High School, Paddington 1903-1966
Christian Brothers College, Rose Bay 1935-1968
Christian Brothers’ Rozelle 1892-1965
Christian Brothers’ School, Macquarie Street, Sydney 1843-1847
Christian Brothers College, Tamworth Now McCarthy Catholic College
Christian Brothers’ High School, Lewisham 1891-present
Eddy’s Annexe, Corrimal
Edmund Rice College, West Wollongong
Kildare Catholic College, Wagga Wagga Previously Christian Brothers High School and St Michael’s College
McCarthy Catholic College, Tamworth
St Charles’ School, Waverley 1892-1968
St Dominic’s College, Penrith Including the Obley Education Centre
St Edmund’s School, Wahroonga For children with vision impairment
St Edward’s College, East Gosford
St Gabriel’s School, Castle Hill For children with hearing impairment
St Joseph’s Primary School, Walgett
St Mary’s Cathedral College, Sydney 1911-present
St Patrick’s College, Strathfield 1928-present
St Patrick’s College, Sutherland 1956-1993
St Paul’s Catholic College, Manly
St Pius X College, Chatswood
St Thomas’s Christian Brothers’ College, Lewisham 1889-1980
Trinity Catholic College, Goulburn Previously St Patrick’s College
Waverley College, Waverley 1903-present

Queensland

School or institution Status and former names
Aquinas College, Southport Formerly Christian Brothers’ College, Southport
Assumption College, Warwick Formerly Christian Brothers’ College, Warwick
Centre Education Programme, Kingston
Christian Brothers’ College, Bundaberg Now Shalom Catholic College
Christian Brothers’ College, Maryborough Now St Mary’s College, Maryborough
Christian Brothers’ College, Gympie Now St Patrick’s College, Gympie
Clairvaux MacKillop College, Brisbane
Columba Catholic College, Charters Towers Formerly Mount Carmel College
Gilroy Santa Maria College, Ingham
Good Shepherd Catholic College, Mount Isa
Ignatius Park College, Townsville
Nudgee International College, Boondall
Nudgee Junior College, Indooroopilly Now Ambrose Treacy College
Our Lady of the Southern Cross College, Dalby
St Brendan’s College, Yeppoon
St Columban’s College, Caboolture
St Edmund’s College, Ipswich
St James’ College, Brisbane
St Joseph’s College, Gregory Terrace, Brisbane
St Joseph’s Nudgee College, Brisbane
St Joseph’s College, Toowoomba
St Laurence’s College, South Brisbane
St Mary’s Catholic College, Dalby
St Mary’s College, Toowoomba
St Patrick’s College, Mackay
St Patrick’s College, Shorncliffe
St Teresa’s College, Abergowrie
The Cathedral College, Rockhampton Formerly Christian Brothers’ College, Rockhampton

South Australia

School or institution Status and former names
Christian Brothers College, Adelaide
Rostrevor College, Woodforde
St Paul’s College, Adelaide

Tasmania

School or institution Status and former names
St Virgil’s College, Hobart
St Brendan’s College for Boys Now St Brendan-Shaw College

Victoria

School or institution Status and former names
Aquinas College, Melbourne
Cathedral College, East Melbourne Closed 1995
Chanel College, Geelong Closed 1999
Christian Brothers College, St Kilda
Damascus College, Ballarat Formed in 1995 when St Paul’s Technical College merged with two other schools
Mount Carmel College, Middle Park Closed
Parade College, Bundoora
St Alipius Boys’ School, Ballarat East Closed 1976
St Augustine’s Orphanage and School, Whittington, Geelong Became part of MacKillop Family Services in 1997
St Augustine’s College, Yarraville Closed 1971
St Bernard’s College, Essendon
St Joseph’s College, Geelong
St Joseph’s College, Melbourne Pascoe Vale and North Melbourne) (closed 2010
St Joseph’s Technical College, South Melbourne
St Kevin’s College, Toorak
St Leo’s College, Box Hill Closed
St Patrick’s College, Ballarat
St Paul’s Technical College, Ballarat Closed 1994, became Damascus College
St Thomas College, Clifton Hill Closed
St Vincent’s Orphanage and School, South Melbourne Became part of MacKillop Family Services in 1997
Therry College, Broadmeadows Closed 1994
St Mary’s Technical School, Geelong Closed
St Joseph’s Christian Brothers College, Warrnambool Closed 1991

Western Australia

School or institution Status and former names
Aquinas College, Salter Point
Aranmore Catholic College
Bindoon Farm School Catholic Agricultural College, Bindoon
Castledare Junior Orphanage, Wilson
Chisholm Catholic College, Perth
St Mary’s Agricultural School, Tardun 1928-2009
Christian Brothers College, Albany A predecessor of St Joseph’s College, Albany
Christian Brothers College, Fremantle
Christian Brothers College, Kalgoorlie Merged with Prendiville College in 1984 to become John Paul College
Christian Brothers’ College, Leederville
Christian Brothers’ College, Highgate Closed
St Vincent’s Orphanage, Clontarf Now Clontarf Aboriginal College, Waterford
St Patrick’s College, Geraldton Merged with Stella Maris College in 1994 to become Nagle Catholic College
Trinity College, Perth

Frequently asked questions

What did the Royal Commission find about the Christian Brothers?

Data released by the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse in 2017 showed that 22% of Christian Brothers who ministered in Australia between 1950 and 2010 were alleged perpetrators of child sexual abuse. The Commission also examined the order’s Western Australian orphanages and farm schools in Case Study 11, and its Ballarat schools in Case Study 28.

Who is responsible for claims against the Christian Brothers now?

In July 2026, Edmund Rice Education Australia agreed, subject to creditor and court approval of a revised scheme of arrangement, to become the defendant in abuse claims against the Christian Brothers and to pay settlements and judgments. Read our guide to Christian Brothers and Edmund Rice Education Australia abuse compensation claims.

Is it too late to make a claim for abuse at a Christian Brothers school?

In New South Wales, time limits for civil claims for child sexual abuse have been removed, so in most cases there is no deadline, although individual circumstances still matter. If you were abused at a Christian Brothers school or home, you can get confidential advice about your options at any time. See our guide to limitation periods for historical institutional abuse claims.

Should I apply to the National Redress Scheme or make a civil claim?

For most survivors with a viable civil claim, a civil claim is the better option. Civil compensation is not capped and reflects the actual harm you have suffered. The National Redress Scheme’s maximum payment is $150,000, and accepting a payment permanently extinguishes your right to bring a civil claim. Applications close on 30 June 2027. We strongly recommend independent legal advice before applying. Read 5 things you should know about the National Redress Scheme.

Talk to us confidentially

If you or someone you know is living with the effects of abuse at a Christian Brothers school or institution, you do not have to work out your options alone. The effects of childhood abuse often continue for decades, and it is never too late to talk to someone. Speaking with us is confidential, and there is no obligation to take any further step. Call Ross Koffel on 02 9283 5599 or send us a message using the form below.

Sources

1 replies to Christian Brothers Sexual Abuse

Leave a public comment

Comments posted here are published publicly on our website and visible to everyone. Please don't share personal details, describe your legal matter, or ask for legal advice through this form. For confidential enquiries, phone us on (02) 9283 5599 or use our contact form.

Ross Koffel

Request a free consultation