Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle appeals landmark AA abuse ruling
Update, February 2026: This article was first published in December 2024. The NSW Court of Appeal allowed the Diocese’s appeal in April 2025. On 11 February 2026 the High Court allowed AA’s appeal, finding that the Diocese owed AA a non-delegable duty of care and breached it. Read our reports on the High Court’s decision and what the case means for survivors.
AA v Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle: case timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 20 September 2024 | NSW Supreme Court finds the Diocese liable for the abuse of AA by Father Ron Pickin |
| 18 October 2024 | Judgment entered for AA for $636,480 |
| 4 November 2024 | Diocese files its appeal in the NSW Court of Appeal |
| 15 April 2025 | Court of Appeal allows the Diocese’s appeal |
| 17 June 2025 | High Court grants AA special leave to appeal |
| 11 February 2026 | High Court allows AA’s appeal, finding the Diocese owed and breached a non-delegable duty of care |
The Catholic Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle has appealed a landmark NSW Supreme Court ruling that found it directly and vicariously liable for the sexual abuse of a Wallsend High School student in 1969. The judgment awarded the survivor, known as AA, more than $600,000, and the appeal raises significant questions about the scope of institutional responsibility in abuse cases.
The Diocese is challenging both the finding that the abuse occurred and the finding of negligence. The case could set a new precedent on the non-delegable duty of care owed by religious institutions.
AA, who is terminally ill, was abused by Father Ron Pickin, the parish priest at St Patrick’s Catholic Church in Wallsend, who taught scripture classes at the high school. The Diocese has also applied to delay payment of the damages until its appeal is heard in February 2025.
“An egregious circumstance”
Sarah McLellan, then Special Counsel at Koffels Solicitors & Barristers, who had acted for AA since December 2022, criticised the Diocese’s decision to appeal given the evidence against it.
“The High Court decision has spoken for us in relation to the prospect of defending the vicarious liability determination. However, the Diocese has also based its grounds of appeal on factual findings of her Honour, including that the sexual abuse took place, together with the negligence finding,” Ms McLellan said.
“This is a man who has been found to have been seriously sexually abused by a priest in circumstances where the Diocese knew or should have known that this priest was abusing children.
“One of the witnesses at the hearing gave evidence that he told two priests, prior to our client being abused, that this priest had abused him.
“This couldn’t be more an egregious circumstance for a religious organisation to be contesting a fairly modest award from a dying man already found by the Supreme Court to have been sexually assaulted by Father Pickin on church premises.”
The question of non-delegable duty
The High Court’s decision in Bird v DP narrowed the scope of vicarious liability. Ms McLellan said the appeal brings forward another critical argument: whether the Diocese owed a non-delegable duty of care to AA as a child on its premises.
“While the door may have closed on the question of ‘vicarious liability’, in the appeal, we will argue that the Diocese owed a non-delegable duty of care to a child on its premises and that there was a breach of this duty, which is an area of law not yet tested in the context of a religious institution,” Ms McLellan said.
The High Court left room for this argument in Bird v DP, and Ms McLellan pointed to a provision of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) that treats a breach of a non-delegable duty in the same way as vicarious liability.
“There’s a provision in the Civil Liability Act which states that a breach of a non-delegable duty will be considered the same as vicarious liability, but that hasn’t been ventilated in the courts as yet,” she explained.
“It’s a very hot topic in the legal profession as to the circumstances in which an entity be found to have owed a non-delegable duty of care outside of the established relationships, such as school authorities with students, hospitals with patients, or prison authorities to prisoners. These relationships are based, in part, on an element of control by a defendant or the vulnerability of a plaintiff.
“So that’s certainly something that will be a very hot topic for the next 18 months or so.”
AA has raised the argument in a notice of contention. If the Court of Appeal rejects it, Ms McLellan said it would “no doubt” need to go to the High Court for final determination.
Delaying justice
On 17 December 2024, Acting Justice Schmidt heard the Diocese’s application for a stay, which, if granted, would prevent AA from receiving his damages until the appeal is resolved. Given AA’s terminal illness, the outcome could determine whether he sees justice delivered in his lifetime.
The bigger picture
For survivors of institutional abuse, the AA case shows how hard it can be to hold powerful institutions to account, even when the evidence is clear. It also highlights an emerging legal debate about non-delegable duties and the responsibilities of religious organisations.
With the Diocese continuing to contest the findings, AA’s case could prove pivotal in defining how institutions are held responsible for protecting the children in their care.
Talk to us
If you were abused as a child by a priest or by someone connected with a church or other institution, you may be able to claim compensation. NSW has removed time limits for civil child sexual abuse claims, so in most cases it is not too late to act, although individual circumstances still matter. Read more about church abuse compensation, or call us on 02 9283 5599 for a confidential conversation.
